Neglect of India’s health system fueled its Covid catastrophe


Covid-19 is surging uncontrollably all through India, disrupting large cities like Mumbai and devastating rural areas the place there’s excessive poverty and hardly any well being care. The guts-rending photos of funeral pyres arrange in public parks, burning an limitless line of our bodies, is simply a glimpse into the tragedy unfolding throughout the nation.

Individuals are ready exterior hospitals — the place there are not any beds and even oxygen — in 100-degree warmth with their sick and dying family members.

The professional-nationalist authorities of Narendra Modi is partly in charge for not stopping the Kumbh Mela Hindu spiritual celebration that introduced 2.5 million folks to the Ganges River, and for carrying on with political rallies that attracted lots of individuals. However excess of hypernationalism is chargeable for this disaster.


In the course of the 20 years that I reported on well being for The Instances of India and educated reporters to cowl this beat, I noticed how the well being sector was uncared for throughout India’s development and growth.

India’s well being care system was envisaged quickly after its independence in 1947 as a three-tier system that would cowl your entire nation. It was to have a main care system on the village stage, a secondary care system to cowl smaller city facilities, and tertiary care for specialised therapy. Through the years, although, the emphasis moved to for-profit tertiary care hospitals, primarily in large cities, with state-of-the-art that supplied care primarily to the city wealthy. Earnings from these hospitals, which go into paying the excessive salaries of medical doctors and high executives, took priority over makes an attempt to control them or cease malpractice, equivalent to overcharging sufferers or pointless surgical procedures.


Successive governments earlier than Modi’s supported this unplanned development, paying little heed to the well being infrastructure that was underfunded, poorly staffed, and falling aside. Sushma Swaraj, a senior politician within the Bharatiya Janata social gathering — in the present day’s ruling social gathering — who I interviewed in 1999 on the social gathering’s absence of concentrate on well being care in its parliamentary election manifesto, informed me, “Well being is a factor for the wealthy. We in India need to concentrate on getting bread to the poor.”

Leaders from different political events voiced comparable views. Few within the authorities or the legacy media thought-about well being care to be a problem of nationwide significance.

I’ve lined epidemics and pandemics up to now, although nothing as tragic because the unfold of Covid-19 in India, and have seen the ensuing chaos. In 1994, for instance, after information emerged of circumstances of pneumonic plague in India, rumors of an airborne an infection of plague prompted 1000’s to flee the town of Surat in western India and be admitted to hospitals in Delhi. There, as I discovered in my reporting, a specialised Hospital for Infectious Illnesses was utterly missing in assets. I’ve additionally seen households wiped away within the AIDS epidemic in India’s villages with little entry to testing or therapy and little consideration paid to them by the federal government or the media.

The actual fact is that the poor in India have struggled to get well being care for many years. Most well being expenditures in India are paid for out of pocket and paying for well being care is among the many main issues that push folks under the poverty line. A 2017 examine by the Public Well being Basis of India discovered that well being bills had been chargeable for driving 55 million Indians into poverty between 2011 and 2012. As many as 90% of the poor don’t have any medical insurance.

Authorities after authorities has promoted medical tourism that entices folks from america and different international locations to return to India’s for-profit hospitals for dental, beauty, and different procedures. India’s ministry of tourism lately expanded its visa regime to permit e-tourist visas for medical tourism, a $3 billion business that’s anticipated to develop within the years forward.

This has been on the expense of neglecting the huge community of well being programs designed to serve the poor, who’ve at all times taken the brunt of neglecting public well being.

The dearth of oxygen to deal with folks with Covid-19 has drawn worldwide consideration. However this isn’t the primary time the oxygen provide has been damaged. Yr after 12 months, India’s northern state of Uttar Pradesh sees outbreaks of Japanese encephalitis amongst kids, a illness unfold by the chew of a mosquito. In 2017, 30 kids died out of the blue at a hospital, seemingly as a result of a disruption in oxygen provide, although that would not be conclusively confirmed. It’s, nevertheless, a reminder of what’s occurring in hospitals throughout India which were working out of high-flow oxygen, leading to deaths.

With little or no demand for enchancment in well being care from the center class and elites, India’s public well being system has taken an enormous hit through the years. Covid-19 has strained it to the breaking level and past, driving folks from villages and smaller cities into larger city facilities which can be already unable to handle the surge of sufferers.

Within the warmth of the second, it’s straightforward in charge the Modi authorities for India’s feeble response to the Covid-19 surge. However bringing lasting change would require a protracted arduous take a look at the planning and neglect of the previous 74 years in impartial India — each by India’s ruling courses and the media.

Kalpana Jain is a senior editor for ethics and faith at The Dialog U.S., a former reporter for the Instances of India, a former Nieman International Well being Reporting Fellow, and writer of “Constructive Lives: The Story of Ashok and others residing with HIV” (Penguin International, 2003).


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here