Masked, Vaccinated and COVID-19 Positive: Why Some Teachers Say This Year’s Precautions Are Still Not Enough


Highschool librarian Nicci Francis managed to keep away from COVID-19 final 12 months. 

Even after her husband, a trainer in Piedmont, the district the place she additionally works, and her son examined constructive in November, Francis managed to keep away from the virus. She credit the protection measures taken by her district.  

Piedmont required masks for all college students and employees. It diminished the variety of college students in its faculties with an alternating days schedule for a lot of the 12 months. Quarantines and isolation had been obligatory and enforced.

When faculties returned in August, Francis mentioned, it was “full steam” forward. Like many Oklahoma districts, many precautions taken the earlier 12 months had been lifted. 

Francis, 46, mentioned she obtained her vaccination in March. She donned a masks on the primary day of faculty, as beneficial by her district. However after seeing few different masked individuals, she stopped. 

She interacted with a whole bunch of scholars within the first few days of faculty, trying out Chromebooks and supervising college students taking digital or concurrent lessons. A headache prompted her to take a COVID-19 take a look at and it got here again constructive.  

“We made all of it final 12 months. We did the proper issues. We received vaccinated. Wore our masks. Tried to remain distanced from individuals,” Francis mentioned. 

“And simply because there are actually no precautions this 12 months, I made it every week.” 

Her signs, which included headache, fatigue, lack of urge for food and abdomen ache, had been gentle. She has since recovered and returned to work. 

For a lot of others, the virus has been lethal. A pre-Okay trainer’s aide in Yukon Public Colleges died Sept. 12, faculty district officers confirmed. A Go Fund Me web page arrange by her household mentioned Erin Rhodes had been on a ventilator with a collapsed lung as a result of COVID-19. 

Different latest Oklahoma educator deaths embrace a 70-year-old Carney elementary trainer named Peggy Hageman, and 59-year-old Connie Tatum, a Stonewall elementary trainer, in accordance with Training Week, a nationwide publication for lecturers that has been created a memorial to the educators who’ve died of coronavirus.

Tatum fell ailing earlier than returning to high school this 12 months and died Aug. 25. It’s unknown whether or not Rhodes or Hageman, who died Sept. 3, had been at school. 

Not less than 1,065 present and retired educators and faculty personnel nationally died of COVID-19 as of Sept. 10, Training Week discovered. Of these, 334 had been lively lecturers. 

Educators returned to high school with a layer of safety unavailable most of final 12 months — the COVID vaccine. However lecturers who’ve skilled breakthrough infections illustrate the bounds of private accountability. A number of lecturers informed Oklahoma Watch they took the precautions being suggested by public well being officers however nonetheless contracted the virus that has killed almost 10,000 Oklahomans since 2020. 

An estimated one in 4 lecturers have well being circumstances that put them at increased danger of significant sickness in the event that they contract COVID-19, in accordance with an evaluation by the Kaiser Household Basis launched final 12 months. 

Oklahoma prioritized educator entry to vaccines, opening doses to lecturers in late February. It’s unknown what share of state lecturers are vaccinated however a ballot by the Nationwide Training Affiliation, the nation’s largest lecturers union, discovered 87% of its members had obtained a minimum of one dose. The Oklahoma Training Affiliation is polling its members and plans to launch these outcomes quickly.

Even when trainer vaccination charges are excessive, college students’ charges are low. The overwhelming majority of Oklahoma’s school-aged kids are unvaccinated.

For these beneath 12, there isn’t a authorized vaccine, although one is anticipated to obtain emergency-use approval this fall. Pfizer-BioNTech introduced Monday its COVID-19 vaccine has been proven to be protected and efficient in kids ages 5 to 11. 

Adolescents 12 to 18 years outdated are eligible to obtain the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine, however they nonetheless want parental consent. Solely a couple of quarter of kids in that age group had been absolutely vaccinated as of Sept. 13, state Well being Division information reveals.

Protecting Measures Past Masks

Public well being businesses emphasised the significance of common masking as college students returned to high school this 12 months. However districts had been hamstrung by Senate Invoice 658, signed into legislation by Gov. Kevin Stitt in Might, when coronavirus circumstances had been declining. A late-summer surge pushed by the delta variant has pushed up circumstances and hospitalizations.  

The legislation successfully bans masks mandates in faculties by limiting when faculty boards can provoke such a requirement. Districts began the 12 months merely encouraging masks carrying.

A number of districts defied the legislation, beginning with Santa Fe South constitution faculty on Aug. 11 and shortly adopted by Oklahoma Metropolis Public Colleges. After the choose positioned the legislation on maintain briefly earlier this month, Edmond, Yukon, Midwest Metropolis-Del Metropolis, Noble, and Union had been among the many districts implementing masks mandates. 

Piedmont, the place Francis works, briefly introduced again obligatory quarantines this 12 months, superintendent James White mentioned, however doesn’t mandate masks carrying. The district of 4,900 college students has already surpassed its coronavirus case complete for 2020-21. As of Sept. 15, the district reported 27 lively circumstances, down from a semester-high of about 90. 

Final week, the college board voted to maneuver again to suggest quarantines for uncovered college students. White mentioned not many individuals had been taking the advice. 

Well being officers’ steerage on quarantine has loosened since final 12 months. 

In December, faculties had been informed that protecting at residence an individual who was in shut contact with somebody who examined constructive for COVID-19 was “important to regulate transmission” and required by state legislation.  

The state Well being Division now solely recommends quarantines for uncovered college students, regardless of the elevated transmissibility of the delta variant. Many districts began the 12 months making quarantines non-compulsory. 

In August, steerage to districts issued by the Training Division re-emphasized obligatory quarantines and a few districts moved to that mannequin. Nevertheless, the well being division’s stance has not modified, mentioned Keith Reed, deputy commissioner of well being.

“We do not need the capability to have the ability to implement such a suggestion, due to this fact it stays a suggestion,” Reed mentioned Thursday.

‘Academics Aren’t Being Protected, Neither Are College students’

One other main distinction this 12 months is the variety of college students at school buildings. Though the official pupil depend doesn’t happen till Oct. 1, there are indicators extra households have chosen in-person faculty. 

Enrollment is down at Epic Constitution Colleges, the state’s largest on-line faculty system. Epic had about 38,000 college students as of final week; in comparison with almost 60,000 final fall. 

Edmond, for example, says enrollment in its digital program is down by about 90 college students however total enrollment within the district is up by greater than 1,900 college students in comparison with final 12 months. Equally, Oklahoma Metropolis Public Colleges reported 1,000 fewer college students in its digital program, and total enrollment is up by greater than 1,200. 

Final 12 months, many massive districts used an alternating days schedule, generally protecting half of the scholars at residence every day to entry faculty content material by way of distance studying, to cut back potential publicity. 

Oklahoma Watch couldn’t discover any utilizing that schedule this 12 months. 

Alternating days schedule is tough for lecturers and fogeys to handle. Plus, state and federal leaders have pushed for a return to in-person faculty 5 days every week. 

For presidency trainer Aaron Baker, some class sizes have tripled. Baker teaches at Putnam Metropolis North Excessive Faculty and prevented the virus for your complete 2020-21 faculty 12 months. 

When the nation floor to a halt in March 2020, he stopped going out to eating places. He went months with out visiting his mother and father and prolonged household. 

His lessons had been nearly completely digital final fall. District lecturers and college students returned to the classroom within the spring on an alternating days schedule. 

Baker, 44, was vaccinated, alongside along with his spouse and their three youngsters after they grew to become eligible, he mentioned. Like many individuals, they widened their bubble, vacationing in Gulf Shores, Ala. He and his spouse celebrated their fifth wedding ceremony anniversary with dinner at a fondue restaurant. 

Nonetheless, he masked up within the grocery retailer and stored out of crowded public areas. In school, he taught from behind a masks, eradicating it solely to explain the day’s lesson and an occasional sip of water.


A Digital Memorial To Oklahomans Who Died

To supply a clearer image of the pandemic’s affect and to memorialize those who we misplaced, Oklahoma Watch is making a database of Oklahomans who died of COVID-19.

On the eighth day of faculty, Baker developed a sore throat. He began coughing. A coronavirus take a look at got here again constructive. 

Over the subsequent few days, remoted at residence, he developed lots of the basic COVID-19 signs: fever, headache, congestion, and a lack of style. For a self-described foodie, that final one hit arduous. 

He wrote a weblog submit titled “Oklahoma Senate BIll 658 Gave Me COVID-19.”  

Baker was offended on the legislature and Stitt for stripping faculties of the flexibility to mandate masks. When Senate Invoice 658 was handed, coronavirus circumstances had been declining and Baker thought faculties wouldn’t want masks within the fall. However by August he had modified his thoughts. 

“I’m optimistic sufficient to hope that they (the legislature) didn’t want this upon me and others,” he mentioned. “I additionally marvel if there are legislators who would take their vote again at this level, understanding what we all know now.”

Home Democrats are trying to repeal the legislation, however the legislature has not taken it up. 

Baker’s faculty district, nonetheless, did reverse course. The Putnam Metropolis faculty board voted Sept. 7 to require masks for all college students and employees. 

In some districts, widespread trainer absences have led to closings and shifts to distance studying. 

Dickson Public Colleges, a district of 1,300 in Ardmore, closed on Aug. 20 and moved college students to distance studying for 10 days. Greater than 10% of employees had been out as a result of COVID when the choice was made, or about 14 of the 135 employees, superintendent Jeff Colclasure mentioned. He declined to say what number of had been vaccinated however mentioned a minimum of among the impacted employees members had been. 

“We reached a degree the place we weren’t in a position to employees successfully,” mentioned Colclasure. “Earlier than delta, all of us felt pretty good about the place we had been and felt like we’d have a standard return to high school. I didn’t suppose it might be like this, actually not this early.” Dickson reopened on Sept. 7. 

Tulsa Public Colleges, too, has needed to shut some faculties as a result of a scarcity of employees. 

Jami Cole, a fifth-grade math trainer in Duncan, is recovering from her second spherical of COVID-19 because the begin of the pandemic. She began feeling drained on the second day of faculty and that weekend developed a headache and allergy-like signs that prompted her to take a take a look at. 

She mentioned she possible contracted the virus through the faculty’s open home evening the Tuesday earlier than faculty began.

Cole has Rheumatoid arthritis, an autoimmune illness during which her immune system assaults wholesome cells by mistake. It means her dangers from COVID-19 are increased than most individuals. 

And her husband has leukemia, including to their family danger. 

Her faculty district doesn’t require masks because it did for many of final 12 months. 

“Academics aren’t being protected, and neither are college students,” Cole mentioned. “I actually really feel disposable.”

Cole first contracted COVID-19 in November. When she caught it the second time in August, she was absolutely vaccinated. Nonetheless, she developed a fever of 102 levels, prompting her physician to prescribe an antibody infusion. She traveled to a hospital an hour away to obtain the infusion, which helped her signs enhance, although she nonetheless will get out of breath simply. 

“The vaccines are nice, and the vaccines do what they’re presupposed to do. They assist hold you out of the hospital. However they’re not protecting individuals from being sick,” she mentioned. 

She’s the one fifth-grade math trainer in her faculty and she or he missed a full week and a half. She returned with a $300 air air purifier bought along with her personal cash.

“Subsequent 12 months, I’m unsure that I’m going to be instructing. That’s kinda what I’m proper now, which is simply devastating,” mentioned Cole, who moderates a non-public Fb group with 62,000 members. 

“I’m not the one one feeling that. Numerous lecturers are. A number of them have mentioned ‘we simply felt like we’re sitting geese. We’re simply ready for us to be recognized.’ “

Jennifer Palmer has been a reporter with Oklahoma Watch since 2016 and covers schooling. Contact her at (405) 761-0093 or Observe her on Twitter @jpalmerOKC

Creative Commons License

Help our publication

Day-after-day we try to provide journalism that issues — tales that strengthen accountability and transparency, present worth and resonate with readers such as you.

This work is important to a better-informed group and a wholesome democracy. However it isn’t potential with out your assist.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here