Fake news alert: Taiwan fights disinformation as COVID surges | Coronavirus pandemic News


Taipei, Taiwan – Rinsing your mouth with sizzling water for half-hour and swallowing will enable your abdomen acid to kill COVID-19. Taking a sizzling tub commonly may also stop you from getting the virus.

These are simply a number of the items of recommendation given in a seven-minute audio clip of a girl claiming to be Taiwanese legislator Tsai Pi-ru circulating on the social messaging app LINE over the previous week.

It comes with the accompanying be aware in conventional Chinese language: “Crucial! Hearken to the entire thing! It’s Tsai Pi-ru sharing (data), I listened to it twice, in your reference.”

The audio clip and the recommendation have each turned out to be pretend and Tsai, a skilled nurse who has volunteered in hospitals in the course of the pandemic, has moved rapidly to debunk them. However such posts have mushroomed on Taiwanese social media for the reason that island’s most severe outbreak but of COVID-19 started earlier this month.

“Ranging from Might 12 (the day after Taiwan declared group transmission), there was lots of disinformation that’s attempting to set off panic domestically in Taiwan,” mentioned Puma Shen, the director of the DoubleThink Labs, a Taipei based-NGO that tracks disinformation and digital surveillance.

The disinformation campaigns have taken various guises over the previous month, he mentioned.

First, they appeared on Twitter accounts, then on YouTube and in particular person and group chats on LINE. After that, voice messages claiming to be from members of Taiwan’s elite started popping up.

In latest days, pretend posts from information websites such because the left-leaning Liberty Instances and pro-democracy Hong Kong publication Apple Every day have additionally been posted on Fb pages directed at animal lovers and supporters of President Tsai Ing-wen, claiming that she and different political elites had secretly contracted COVID-19, Shen mentioned.

Pretend information has additionally been accompanied by what Shen calls “propaganda” posts with claims comparable to China providing to promote its COVID-19 vaccine to Taiwan, which has struggled over the previous 12 months to acquire enough doses for its inhabitants of 23 million – though a home vaccine is because of roll out this summer time.

Sowing discord and panic

Whereas disinformation campaigns are nothing new in Taiwan, which is commonly focused by China’s well-oiled propaganda machine and its native supporters, the latest COVID-19 marketing campaign has severe well being implications.

Over the weekend, Deputy Minister of the Inside Chen Tsung-yen mentioned posts in regards to the president’s well being had been “actually vile pretend information” that amounted to “cognitive warfare” in opposition to the Taiwanese.

“In comparison with final 12 months, this 12 months is far worse and severe misinformation and one of many causes the general public is in panic,” mentioned Robin Lee, the mission supervisor of MyGoPen, an unbiased fact-checking web site in Taiwan whose English identify is much like the Taiwanese pronunciation of “Don’t Lie”.

Taiwan has stepped up COVID-19 restrictions to sort out a brand new outbreak of the virus, which has additionally been accompanied by a flood of disinformation shared on social media [Chiang Ying-ying/AP Photo]

Taiwanese society has been notably uncovered to pretend information over the previous month because it grapples with its first nationwide partial lockdown after a 12 months and a half of efficiently containing the virus.

Though each day instances vary between 200 and 300 – low in contrast with neighbours like Japan – the outbreak is probably the most severe but and an enormous morale loss in some quarters.

Final 12 months, Taiwan went for greater than 250 days with no single native coronavirus case and till the top of April, the full variety of native instances hovered at roughly 1,200 due to an aggressive contact-tracing programme and obligatory 14-day quarantine for travellers.

Nevertheless, the latest outbreak has been linked to pilots on the nationwide service China Airways – who must endure a shorter quarantine interval – and has led to the federal government closing colleges throughout the island for the primary time since early 2020 and calling for residents to work at home when potential.

Pretend information island

As rapid-testing stations sprang up round Taiwan and panic-buying returned, quickly clearing the moment noodle sections of many grocery shops, pretend information additionally made a comeback. However this time round, most of the posts and messages appeared extra plausible.

Beforehand, pretend information and propaganda posts from China had been straightforward to identify: simplified Chinese language (used on the the mainland) would often creep in or include phrases that the Taiwanese themselves would discover odd. However this time spherical the brand new cache of posts appeared way more credible.

A brand new wave of audio messages funded by Chinese language authorities businesses is now making the rounds. In line with a 2020 report from American cybersecurity agency Recorded Future, native Taiwanese at the moment are paid between $730 and $1,460 a month to supply social media posts – near the typical month-to-month wage on the island – to put in writing and voice these scripts.

As Fb has cracked down on misinformation and faux information, viral messages have migrated to LINE, YouTube, Instagram, and PTT, Taiwan’s model of Reddit. Latest posts have targeted on COVID-19 however have additionally taken on Taiwan’s 2020 presidential election and Tsai who was then operating for a second time period as president.


Zongchai, the CDC’s Shiba Inu mascot, reminds residents to keep up social distancing and put on face masks to regulate the COVID-19 epidemic.

A lot of this work, however not all, has been linked to China’s United Entrance Work Division, the Communist Youth League, and an unbiased military of web trolls, based on the US-based Heart for Strategic and Worldwide Research.

A few of additionally it is produced domestically by Taiwanese who could help nearer ties to China, which claims the island as its personal, or who merely dislike the Tsai administration, CSIS mentioned.

Movies, specifically, have been traced to content material farms operated by ethnic Chinese language in Malaysia, mentioned DoubleThink Labs’ Shen.

Cute assault

MyGoPen and the Taiwan FactCheck Heart are simply two organisations working domestically to dispel disinformation campaigns, debunking pretend information on their web sites after which sharing data throughout social media accounts.

The Heart for Illness Management stay streams its each day afternoon press conferences throughout a number of platforms to tell Taiwanese of the newest statistics and well being protocols however it has additionally relied on humour and memes to sort out disinformation.

A profitable marketing campaign has featured Zongchai, the Centre for Illness Management’s Shiba Inu canine mascot. Zongchai commonly seems in messages from the CDC about latest case figures and sensible recommendation, comparable to the proper size for social distancing: i.e. the size of three Shiba Inus lined up nose-to-nose.

Whereas informative, the messages play properly into Taiwanese’s appreciation for cute memes, the place even Taiwan’s authoritarian ruler Chiang Kai-shek has been given the cartoon therapy in LINE posts from his one-time get together, the Kuomintang.

Zongchai’s pigeon mascot for the Ministry of Overseas Affairs, which commonly pronounces modifications in Taiwan’s journey restrictions, are all a part of its “2-2-2” response to disinformation: reply in 20 minutes with 200 phrases and two photographs that prioritise “humour over hearsay”.

(Translation: Put up from 24/5/2021. ‘Suspected mass burning of our bodies from Wanhua pneumonia’. False data unfold on web site] 

This so-called “meme engineering” is meant to “package deal the message in such a humorous means that you just must share it,” Taiwan’s digital minister Audrey Tang informed France’s Basis for Strategic Analysis in April final 12 months.

However for each cute Shiba Inu publish the CDC churns out, one other pretend message seems.

Earlier this week, MyGoPen debunked a hearsay that the US had so many additional vaccine doses that that they had begun inoculating cats and canine. One other message claimed the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine is barely 29.5 p.c efficient regardless of scientific information reporting efficacy charges above 90 p.c for the unique virus and newly-emerged variants

One factor is for certain: as Taiwan battles furiously to tamp down this newest wave of infections, it will likely be working double-time to stamp out the pretend memes.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here