FactCheck: Already Had COVID-19? Vaccines Boost Immunity, Not ‘Wipe Out’ Antibodies


Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms prepares to get vaccinated by Dr. Carlos del Rio, MD at Mercedes-Benz Stadium on Tuesday, March 30, 2021 in Atlanta. Del Rio is chair of the Division of World Well being on the Rollins Faculty of Public Well being at Emory College’s Faculty of Drugs. (Picture: Itoro N. Umontuen/The Atlanta Voice)

SciCheck Digest

Research present the COVID-19 vaccines increase the antibody ranges and enhance the immune response of those that beforehand had COVID-19. The vaccines don’t “wipe out” the antibodies developed by an individual who had recovered from the illness, as social media posts have falsely claimed for months.

Full Story

A number of research present that COVID-19 vaccines present extra safety for many who have been beforehand contaminated with SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19. The vaccines are secure and efficient at defending individuals from getting sick, together with those that’ve already recovered from the illness, and don’t “wipe out” pure immunity, as social media posts have falsely claimed.

Dr. Amesh Adalja, an infectious illness knowledgeable and a senior scholar on the Johns Hopkins Heart for Well being Safety, informed FactCheck.org that vaccination doesn’t eradicate, scale back or change the antibodies developed after a earlier an infection in any manner.

“Vaccination augments pure immunity, making it extra strong and extra sturdy,” he mentioned in an e-mail.

But lots of of customers of TikTok have rehashed an audio clip, first revealed as a video earlier this 12 months, that deceitfully claims that COVID-19 vaccines eradicate the coronavirus antibodies developed after a earlier an infection. The TikTok movies, a few of them with over 50,000 and 90,000 likes, present totally different individuals listening and reacting to the audio, which begins with a information anchor asserting a warning relating to the COVID-19 vaccines.

The February clip from KMOV-4, a CBS-affiliated tv station in St. Louis, Missouri, inaccurately says: “The Purple Cross says anybody who has acquired their COVID-19 vaccine can not donate convalescent plasma to assist different COVID-19 sufferers in hospitals. That plasma is made up of antibodies from individuals who have recovered from the virus, however the vaccine wipes out these antibodies.”

The American Purple Cross informed FactCheck.org in an e-mail that “the unique data offered to the native station from the regional communicator was sadly misinterpreted throughout the broadcast.” The information station later corrected the data on Could 27.

The Purple Cross made clear then it was nonetheless accepting blood and plasma donations from vaccinated individuals, however that it had discontinued the convalescent plasma donation program by the tip of March. Plasma is the clear fluid a part of blood, whereas convalescent plasma is the plasma of people that have recovered from a illness, which comprises antibodies to that illness.

The Meals and Drug Administration issued an emergency use authorization for using convalescent plasma from individuals who have recovered from COVID-19 to deal with hospitalized sufferers with the illness on Aug. 23, 2020. On Feb. 4, 2021, after extra research, the FDA revised the EUA to authorize solely using COVID-19 convalescent plasma with excessive ranges of antibodies for the remedy of hospitalized sufferers early in the middle of the illness and people who can not produce an enough antibody response.

Knowledge from scientific trials confirmed no scientific profit in using convalescent plasma with low ranges of antibodies. In its COVID-19 Remedy Tips, the Nationwide Institutes of Well being says a number of randomized scientific trials “haven’t demonstrated the efficacy of convalescent plasma for the remedy of hospitalized sufferers with COVID-19” who should not have impaired immunity, and the NIH suggest towards using it outdoors of a scientific trial. Even for these with with impaired immunity, the NIH mentioned there was “inadequate proof … to suggest both for or towards” using high-titer convalescent plasma.

In a doc providing steering for COVID-19 convalescent plasma donations issued by the FDA in November, earlier than the vaccines have been approved, individuals who had acquired a vaccine by means of a scientific trial weren’t eligible to donate convalescent plasma. That steering was up to date in January, making vaccinated individuals eligible in the event that they’ve had a earlier an infection, acquired a prognosis earlier than they have been vaccinated, and are inside six months of decision of COVID-19 signs. The steering is “to make sure that COVID-19 convalescent plasma collected from donors comprises adequate antibodies instantly associated to their immune responses to COVID-19 an infection.”

The plasma of those that have been vaccinated however who haven’t been contaminated with SARS-CoV-2 just isn’t convalescent plasma, as a result of they have been by no means convalescent. An FDA spokesperson informed us by e-mail: “The info supporting the emergency use authorization of COVID-19 convalescent plasma to deal with sufferers hospitalized with COVID-19 was obtained from plasma donations from people who had COVID-19, not from vaccinated people who didn’t have COVID-19.” The spokesperson mentioned that whereas a vaccinated particular person “is protected against getting COVID-19 … there isn’t any information on whether or not their plasma is perhaps efficient for the remedy of hospitalized COVID-19 sufferers.”

Folks with a earlier an infection and vaccinated individuals develop antibodies to SARS-CoV-2, however there’s a slight distinction. An individual who has been contaminated with the virus produces antibodies to a number of elements of the virus, together with the nucleocapsid protein and others, whereas somebody who will get an FDA-authorized or -approved vaccine solely produces antibodies to the spike protein of the virus. The truth that the FDA included individuals with prior infections who have been later vaccinated as eligible convalescent plasma donors debunks the parable that vaccine-induced antibodies wipe out antibodies developed after a pure an infection.

The Purple Cross didn’t implement the up to date FDA steering, as a result of it stopped amassing convalescent plasma altogether. In an e-mail to FactCheck.org, a Purple Cross consultant mentioned this system was ended due to a decline in demand from hospitals, adequate current provide, and likewise “[c]omplex system modifications” that may be wanted to simply accept convalescent plasma from vaccinated donors.

The Purple Cross informed us it continued to check entire blood donations for COVID-19 antibodies till June 14, 2021, and was in a position to make use of these with excessive ranges of antibodies as convalescent plasma.

In July, the Purple Cross tried to debunk the misinformation with a Q&A on COVID-19 vaccines and blood or plasma donation eligibility.

“There are claims circulating that incorrectly state that the Purple Cross is not going to settle for convalescent plasma donations from those that have acquired the COVID-19 vaccine as a result of ‘the vaccine wipes out these antibodies making the convalescent plasma ineffective in treating different COVID-19 sufferers.’ This isn’t correct,” it says (emphasis is the Purple Cross’).

The claims have since been fact-checked over and over and over, but they proceed to unfold.

Dr. Rachel M. Presti, an affiliate professor of drugs on the Washington College Faculty of Drugs in St. Louis who helped conduct scientific trials for the COVID-19 vaccines and has studied the immune response to SARS-CoV-2 after an infection and vaccination, says there isn’t any proof that the vaccines wipe out pure immunity to SARS-CoV-2, or to every other an infection.

“That may be one thing that may be … very readily plentiful within the trials and particularly within the preliminary security research. You recognize, we will detect, on a typical blood check, how a lot antibody you have got typically, and we don’t see that change considerably after vaccination,” she mentioned in a telephone interview. If the vaccine may wipe out individuals’s total immune system, the billions of vaccinated individuals could be getting infections on a regular basis, she mentioned, “[a]nd we aren’t seeing any of that clinically.”

Vaccination Boosts Immunity

What Presti and different researchers have seen is that the vaccines considerably enhance the immune response to the virus for these with earlier infections. In truth, individuals with earlier infections who get vaccinated develop what researchers are calling “hybrid immunity” and even “super-immunity.”

“What we’ve seen in our research is individuals who received contaminated after which received vaccinated, have greater ranges of antibodies to the spike protein, that protecting antibody, than individuals who simply received vaccinated,” Presti mentioned.

A examine that regarded on the immune response prompted by the mRNA vaccines in individuals with and with out earlier coronavirus infections, revealed by a group from the College of Pennsylvania Perelman Faculty of Drugs in Science Immunology in April, discovered that “in SARS-CoV-2 recovered people, antibody and reminiscence B cell responses have been considerably boosted after the primary vaccine dose.” A more moderen examine revealed by the group in Science in October discovered related outcomes.

Regardless that research have discovered that most individuals who get better from COVID-19 are protected towards reinfection, the power of the immune response amongst individuals can fluctuate and the length of it stays unclear.

“Some individuals even have pretty low antibody responses that aren’t adequate to neutralize the virus, particularly variant viruses. Once you vaccinate them uniformly, you get excessive antibody titers [measurements] and excessive neutralization titers, so there’s an enchancment in at the least one of many key metrics of immunity following vaccination,” E. John Wherry, director of the College of Pennsylvania’s Institute for Immunology and one of many lead authors of the research, informed FactCheck.org in a telephone interview in April.

The Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention recommends individuals who have recovered from COVID-19 get a vaccine as a result of “analysis has not but proven how lengthy you’re protected against getting COVID-19 once more” after recovering, and since “vaccination helps shield you even when you’ve already had COVID-19.”

A CDC examine launched in August discovered unvaccinated Kentucky residents who have been beforehand contaminated with SARS-CoV-2 however remained unvaccinated have been “greater than twice as more likely to be reinfected” with the virus than those that received a vaccine after an an infection.

Not All Nurses and Medical doctors Have Pure Immunity to COVID-19

Within the midst of states and nations requiring well being care staff to get vaccinated, one Instagram publish pushing this declare additionally falsely acknowledged that nurses and medical doctors don’t want vaccines “by definition” as a result of everybody “who has labored in a hospital within the final two years and not using a v now has pure immunity.”

That’s not appropriate. Johns Hopkins’ Adalja informed us that though some nurses and medical doctors “have a level of pure immunity in the event that they have been contaminated with the virus,” research present that not all of them have antibodies.

“For instance, I’ve been caring for COVID sufferers all through the pandemic and had antibodies checked twice earlier than I acquired my vaccine and was unfavorable,” he wrote.

One examine performed by the CDC collected serum samples from frontline well being care staff who labored with COVID-19 sufferers at 13 medical facilities within the U.S. from April 3 to June 19, 2020. It discovered that 6% of three,248 contributors had constructive check outcomes for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies. That’s as a result of the one option to get antibodies towards the coronavirus on the time — earlier than the vaccines have been approved — was to get contaminated by the virus, and never all well being care staff received contaminated.

“Engaged on the frontlines doesn’t essentially provide you with immunity,” Presti informed us. “The rationale that not all medical doctors and nurses received sick and died from COVID isn’t as a result of that they had pure immunity, it’s as a result of they have been sporting protecting gear —  so masks, and robes, and gloves, and face masks, so on.”

The World Well being Group estimated that as of Could 24, at the least 115,000 well being care staff have died from COVID-19 globally. And in keeping with an Worldwide Council of Nurses report revealed in March “hundreds of thousands of COVID-19 infections have been reported amongst healthcare staff globally,” and about 3,000 nurses in 60 nations have died due to COVID-19.

“Nurses, their colleagues, and their friends, stay susceptible to COVID-19, particularly when unvaccinated,” the American Nurses Affiliation, which helps the vaccine mandates, informed FactCheck.org in an e-mail. “Even with pure immunity, vaccination enhances immune response and offers extra safety within the absence of clear information that signifies the length and power of pure immunity within the presence of extremely transmissible variants, comparable to Delta.”

Editor’s observe: SciCheck’s COVID-19/Vaccination Venture is made doable by a grant from the Robert Wooden Johnson Basis. The muse has no management over FactCheck.org’s editorial selections, and the views expressed in our articles don’t essentially replicate the views of the muse. The purpose of the challenge is to extend publicity to correct details about COVID-19 and vaccines, whereas reducing the affect of misinformation.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here